×
☰
Search for an item, seller, zip code or auction

What's in the box?

Hillsdale, New Jersey
Subscribe
Current Auctions
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 5/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 139
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Begins to close
Mon, Feb 17 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 6/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 140
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Begins to close
Wed, Feb 19 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 7/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 141
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Begins to close
Mon, Feb 24 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 8/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 142
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Begins to close
Wed, Feb 26 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
Closed Auctions
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 4/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 138
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Sale closed on
Wed, Feb 12 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 3/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 137
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Sale closed on
Mon, Feb 10 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 2/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 136
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Sale closed on
Wed, Feb 05 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
AuctionNinja
AuctionNinja AuctionNinja
February 1/8 Collectibles & More. Auction # 135
Shipping Only Shipping Available
Sale closed on
Sun, Feb 02 2025 @ 7:00 PM EDT
View More
About Us

What's in the box is an online auction business where you can bid on sports cards, matchbox cars, and all other collectibles. Our auction includes a wide array of sports & collectible cards, comic books, matchbox cars, graded cards, stamps, comic books, and other vintage items.

Payments are accepted in USD and are processed via Stripe.com. Please visit their website for further details.

Customer service is provided via email. whatsinthebox25@gmail.com

Shipping information
Shipping cost is determined by the weight and size of the package, type of package, and destination.
Unpaid shipping will result in the loss of items won in the auction. Items will not be shipped until payment for items and payment for shipping have both been made. Our auctions are shipping only. There is no local pickup option available.

Orders are shipped within 7 - 10 days upon completion of the auction. We do not accept returns.

Business address
215 Lincoln Avenue
Hillsdale, NJ 07642

 

Reviews (89)
Overall
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN4
  • 4.75

Based on 89 reviews

5 Star
77
4 Star
7
3 Star
1
2 Star
1
1 Star
3
Review this seller

Share your thoughts with other bidders.

Write a Bidder Review
Sort by:
Filter by:
Jon

New Jersey

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • August 15, 2023

Excellent Service!

What's in the box?
Thank you so much!! We appreciate the kind words.
 
Marc

New Hampshire

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • August 01, 2023

Awesome

What's in the box?
Thank you so much for the great feedback!!
 
Sydney

Massachusetts

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • July 07, 2023

Shipping was fast and I received the order within a couple days. The item was exactly as posted. Very happy with my purchase and the company.

What's in the box?
Glad you were happy, we try our best to create accurate listings. We try our hardest to provide the most reasonable, and quickest shipping possible. rnThank you so much!!
 
Christopher

New Jersey

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN4
  • AN1
  • June 04, 2023

Shipping was a bit slow.

John

Massachusetts

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • May 31, 2023

🙏

John

Massachusetts

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • May 25, 2023

Great!

Jon

New Jersey

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • April 30, 2023

TY!

What's in the box?
Thank you so much for bidding in our auction!!
 
Noah

Washington

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • April 25, 2023

Got my cards. Good seller

Gary

Michigan

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN1
  • AN1
  • AN1
  • AN1
  • April 18, 2023

Mike sorry I took so long to respond but I was on my winter vacation.Thanks for everything.The items were very well packed, I have all the faith in the world of a future purchase .

What's in the box?
Thank you for the feedback, Gary. I'm not sure if you meant to give us 1 star for each category. If you meant to give us a higher rating, can you please adjust? Thank you!
 
Eric

Maine

Verified Bidder

  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • AN5
  • March 25, 2023

It was an easy transaction and packing and shipping was spot on and fast

View by:
Sort by:
Contact Us

Contact us via email - whatsinthebox25@gmail.com

 

Getting in contact with us is now easier than ever! Just fill out the appropriate fields below and we'll get back to you as soon as possible!

Submit
Privacy Policy

Customer data is stored securely and payments are processed securely via Stripe.com.

Terms & Conditions
Shipping cost is determined by the weight and size of the package, type of package, and destination. 
Unpaid shipping will result in the loss of items won in the auction. Items will not be shipped until payment for items and payment for shipping have both been made.
Top Auction Locations
Albany

New York

Boston

Massachusetts

Burlington

Vermont

Chicago

Illinois

Dallas

Texas

Denver

Colorado

Ft. Lauderdale

Florida

Hartford

Connecticut

Los Angeles

California

New Haven

Connecticut

New York

New York

Philadelphia

Pennsylvania

Plattsburgh

New York

Providence

Rhode Island

Raleigh

North Carolina

San Antonio

Texas

Seattle

Washington

Springfield

Massachusetts

Tacoma

Washington

Washington

District of Columbia

View All Auction Locations

AuctionNinja

AuctionNinja

Bidders

Bidders

Sellers

Sellers

Help
Help
© 2025 AuctionNinja