Dolls Decoded: Finding Value in Today's Doll Market

Estimating the value of a doll blends historical knowledge and detailed examination. From evaluating the materials and craftsmanship, to understanding the doll's provenance, each factor contributes to its overall worth.

Consulting a subject area expert is the only way to ascertain a definitive identification for any given doll. With that being said, you may ascertain a general age and origin with a few basic observations:

1. Composition:

Antique dolls were often made from materials like cloth, bisque (unglazed porcelain), or a mix of wood pulp, glue, and other materials.

Different periods and manufacturers used distinct materials. For example, bisque dolls were popular from the late 19th century to the early 20th century.

2. Manufacturer:

Look for any maker’s marks, stamps, or labels on the doll. These markings can provide clues about the doll’s manufacturer and era.

Notable doll manufacturers include J.D. Kestner, Armand Marseille, and Steiff.

3. Construction:

Many antique dolls have articulated joints that allow their arms and legs to move. The type of jointing can help date the doll. For instance, early dolls often have simple, jointed limbs, while later dolls may have more complex joint systems.

The doll’s head can also provide clues to the date of construction as well. Antique dolls often have glass eyes, which can be stationary or “sleep eyes” (eyes that close when the doll is laid down). Antique doll hair could be real mohair or human hair, whereas modern dolls often have synthetic hair.

4. Clothing:

The style of clothing might offer clues to the doll’s age. For instance, clothing styles from the early 1900s will differ significantly from the 1950s. Look for details like fabric type, construction techniques, and embellishments.

The use of clothing-as-a-clue technique, of course, assumes the difference between reproduction and original clothing is evident. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. Authentic antique clothing will likely show signs of aging such as fading or fraying, whereas reproductions may appear newer.

5. Face and features:

Examine the face for characteristics typical of the doll’s era. For example, early 20th-century dolls often have realistic facial features, while older dolls might have simpler, stylized faces. 

The doll's type of body might also provide valuable clues to the age and manufacture of the doll. The body’s construction (composition, cloth, or wood) and the head's attachment method (e.g., glued or pegged) can help identify the doll’s period. This method can be used to exclude or include periods for the doll’s construction. 

6. Consult Reference Materials and Experts

Use books or online resources that focus on antique dolls. Many books provide detailed information and images that can help with identification. Guides such as Doll Values by Linda Edward or The Collector's Encyclopedia of Dolls by Dorothy S. Coleman can be helpful. 

Combining these methods will give you a comprehensive understanding of your doll's history and value. Remember to always verify your products before selling! 

Sources for this article include: 

The United Federation of Doll Clubs 

DOLLS Magazine

Doll Reference

Written by:

Juli Dupont

August 30, 2024     Updated 03:08 PM

Juli is the customer success guru at AuctionNinja, specializing in helping sellers achieve maximum success on the platform. With a background in the estates and acquisitions department at AuctionNinja's parent company, BRG, Juli possesses a deep understanding of the challenges and dynamics of the auctioneering and estate selling industry. Her expertise makes her the go-to person for sellers navigating the ever-changing marketplace. Juli holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in English.

Ready to locate an estate sale company or explore online estate auctions? Visit AuctionNinja.com. If you're new to online estate auctions, try it risk-free by sigining up here.