The Best Places to Shop Antiques, Vintage and Thrifted Finds in Ocean City and Cape May, NJ

We’ve rounded up a comprehensive list of some of the best places in Cape May to find vintage, antique, consigned and thrifted goods. 

 

Treasures Past Antiques

Antique store, 300 Main St, South Seaville, NJ 08246

 

Located right between Atlantic City and Cape May, Treasures Past Antiques is a treasure trove for Jersey Shore’s residents and visitors alike. Outside, the store houses a variety of outdoor decorations which give a sneak peek into the character-filled historic goods hidden inside. Stop by after your trip to the beach to discover one-of-a-kind treasures you won’t find anywhere else.

 

 

 

 

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A post shared by Treasures Past Antiques (@treasurespast)

 

Capt. Scrap’s Attic

Antique store, 3071 North Route 9, Ocean View, NJ 08230

 

From Victorian-era dressers, vintage comics and beachy jewelry, Captain Scrap’s Attic has something for everyone. Each item in the store is filled with character, and the store specializes in scented handmade soaps created with olive oil and shea butter. Stop by and browse to learn more about the Attic’s many hidden gems and the stories behind them.

Tuckahoe Vintage Goods and Trading Company

Antique store, 2250 NJ-50, Tuckahoe, NJ 08250

 

Tuckahoe Vintage Goods and Trading Company combines late twentieth century’s vintage style with its antique predecessor. The store is filled with both antique and vintage furniture and home decor, and it brings a taste of the beach into its unique style. For those looking to get creative and revamp their furniture with a shabby-chic look, Tuckahoe Vintage Goods and Trading Company has chalk paint available.

Hourglass Antiques and More

Antique store, 2045 U.S. 9, Cape May, NJ 08210

 

With over twelve dealers contributing to its inventory, Hourglass Antiques and More provides a fast-rotating cycle of one-of-a-kind used goods, so there is always something new. The store offers a mix of antique and vintage styles from a variety of time periods prior to the twenty-first century. It even houses a “man-tique” cave filled with vintage tools and trinkets. Stop by to browse its stockpile of many unique, ever-changing collectibles. 

West End Garage

Consignment shop, 484 West Perry Street, Cape May, NJ 08204

 

What once was a garage and gas station is now home to over fifty different antique, vintage, and consignment shops with contributions from 62 vendors from New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. There is an option for everyone who sets foot at the West End Garage, which houses items ranging from antique and estate jewelry to local artwork to vintage memorabilia. Pay the West End Garage a visit after your walk through Wilbraham Park for a shopping experience like no other.

 

 

 

 

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A post shared by WestEndGarage + BeachPlumCafé (@westendgarage)

 

Victorious

Antique store

302 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204

 

Victorious provides a haven for those drawn to the finer things in life. It is stocked full of estate jewelry, designer bags, and a charming boutique. The store features a wide selection of retro-style clothing, with its jewelry adding a designer feel to it. Be sure to browse if you’re looking for a unique, charming way to scale your wardrobe and jewelry collection up.

Queen May

Jewelry store, 325 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204

 

Specializing in jewelry and accessories, Queen May has a wide variety of jewelry, ranging from expensive to a more affordable selection. It is filled with antique jewelry and used designer accessories, from wedding bands and engagement rings to vintage Chanel bags. Queen May offers upscale goods at more accessible prices, giving customers a “thrill of the chase” type of experience.

Out of the Past Antiques

Antique store, 394 Myrtle Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204

 

Founded upon the idea that each item is filled with memories and sentiment, Out of the Past Antiques seeks to provide its visitors with history-rich goods at affordable prices. The store contains various types of antique and vintage treasures from a plethora of different styles and time periods, appealing to customers of every interest and finance. Browse through Out of the Past Antiques to discover one-of-a-kind memorabilia.

Cape May Antique Center

Antique store, 1228 NJ-109, Cape May, NJ 08204

 

With over seventy different vendors, Cape May Antique Center constantly fills its 6,500 square foot store with new and unique merchandise. From antique coins and estate jewelry to vintage sports memorabilia and vinyl records, Cape May Antique Center has something for everyone seeking a journey into the past. Stop by and explore this treasure trove of culture and history.

Treehouse Antiques of Cape May

Antique store, 742 Seashore Road, Cape May, NJ 08204

 

Treehouse Antiques of Cape May invites visitors in with over 3,000 square feet stocked full of antique furniture, china, jewelry, artisan goods, garden ornaments, and more. For those with an eye for historic treasures, Treehouse Antiques of Cape May offers a wide selection of goods from over a century ago. Browse the Treehouse in order to learn more about its items and their unique, rich histories.

 

Have a favorite secondhand hunting ground that didn't make the list? Message us on Instagram @auctionninja and let us know!

 

AuctionNinja Marketplace  

Online estate sales & auctions, www.auctionninja.com / @auctionninja

Listed as one of Buzzfeed's 'Top Life Hacks of 2021', Ocean City and Cape May's online estate sale marketplace offers a broad selection of secondhand goods. From furniture, sports memorabilia and fashion, to coins, household appliances and tools. New auctions are posted daily. Sign up to get new and closing auctions sent directly to your inbox.

Ready to locate an estate sale company or explore online estate auctions? Visit AuctionNinja.com. If you're new to online estate auctions, try it risk-free by sigining up here.